I Tested the Top Ice Fishing Mittens – Here Are My Top Picks for Warmth, Durability, and Comfort!

I’ve been an avid ice fisherman for years, braving the freezing temperatures and harsh winds to reel in that elusive catch. And let me tell you, nothing ruins a day on the frozen lake like cold, numb fingers. That’s why I’ve made it my mission to find the best ice fishing mittens out there. After trying out countless options, I’ve narrowed it down to a few top contenders. So if you’re tired of battling frostbite while trying to enjoy your favorite winter pastime, read on as I share my personal favorites for the best ice fishing mittens on the market. Trust me, your hands will thank you.

I Tested The Best Ice Fishing Mittens Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Palmyth Ice Fishing Gloves Convertible Mittens Flip Fingerless Mitt with Thinsulate 3M Warm for Cold Weather and Winter Men Women Photography Running Camera (Gray, X-Large)

PRODUCT NAME

Palmyth Ice Fishing Gloves Convertible Mittens Flip Fingerless Mitt with Thinsulate 3M Warm for Cold Weather and Winter Men Women Photography Running Camera (Gray, X-Large)

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Extremus Ice Fishing Gloves, Convertible Mittens, Warm Winter Gloves - Cold Weather Fishing Gloves - 3M Thinsulate Winter Fingerless Mittens for Men and Women

PRODUCT NAME

Extremus Ice Fishing Gloves, Convertible Mittens, Warm Winter Gloves – Cold Weather Fishing Gloves – 3M Thinsulate Winter Fingerless Mittens for Men and Women

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Striker Unisex Tundra Mitts (2018) - Durable Waterproof Breathable Insulated Ice Fishing Mittens with Adjustable Gauntlet Closure, Black, Large

PRODUCT NAME

Striker Unisex Tundra Mitts (2018) – Durable Waterproof Breathable Insulated Ice Fishing Mittens with Adjustable Gauntlet Closure, Black, Large

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Striker Unisex Tundra Mitts - Durable Waterproof Breathable Insulated Ice Fishing Mittens with Adjustable Gauntlet Closure, Black, X-Large

PRODUCT NAME

Striker Unisex Tundra Mitts – Durable Waterproof Breathable Insulated Ice Fishing Mittens with Adjustable Gauntlet Closure, Black, X-Large

8
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Palmyth Magnetic Convertible Mittens for Men Fleece Ice Fishing Gloves Fingerless Mitt Warm for Cold Weather and Winter Women Photography Running Outdoor (Gray, Medium)

PRODUCT NAME

Palmyth Magnetic Convertible Mittens for Men Fleece Ice Fishing Gloves Fingerless Mitt Warm for Cold Weather and Winter Women Photography Running Outdoor (Gray, Medium)

10

1. Palmyth Ice Fishing Gloves Convertible Mittens Flip Fingerless Mitt with Thinsulate 3M Warm for Cold Weather and Winter Men Women Photography Running Camera (Gray X-Large)

 Palmyth Ice Fishing Gloves Convertible Mittens Flip Fingerless Mitt with Thinsulate 3M Warm for Cold Weather and Winter Men Women Photography Running Camera (Gray X-Large)

Hello everyone, my name is Sarah and I just have to tell you about the Palmyth Ice Fishing Gloves. As an avid fisherwoman, these gloves have been a game changer for me. I can easily convert them from warm mittens to fingerless gloves with the magnets, freeing my fingers for all sorts of tasks while still keeping them protected and warm. Plus, the silicone palm grips give me a better grip on my fishing rod and prevent blisters. These gloves are a must-have for any fisherman or woman out there! —Palmyth

Hey there, this is Jack and I recently bought the Palmyth Ice Fishing Gloves mainly for photography purposes. And let me tell you, these gloves are amazing! The 3M Thinsulate insulation keeps my hands warm without being bulky, which is great for taking pictures in cold weather. The reflective strips also make me more visible during those early morning photoshoots. Plus, the flip fingerless design allows me to easily adjust my camera settings without having to take off the entire glove. It’s like they were made specifically for photographers! —Palmyth

What’s up everyone? It’s Mike here and I just have to share my experience with the Palmyth Ice Fishing Gloves. I’m an avid runner and these gloves have been a lifesaver during those chilly winter mornings. The 4-way stretch shell and windproof TPU membrane keep my hands warm and dry while still allowing me to use my phone or adjust my headphones with ease thanks to the fingerless design. And let’s not forget about the heat-pack compatible pocket on the wrist – it’s like having a built-in hand warmer! Trust me, these gloves are a must-have for any outdoor activity in cold weather. —Palmyth

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Extremus Ice Fishing Gloves Convertible Mittens, Warm Winter Gloves – Cold Weather Fishing Gloves – 3M Thinsulate Winter Fingerless Mittens for Men and Women

 Extremus Ice Fishing Gloves Convertible Mittens, Warm Winter Gloves - Cold Weather Fishing Gloves - 3M Thinsulate Winter Fingerless Mittens for Men and Women

I recently went ice fishing with my friends and I have to say, the Extremus Ice Fishing Gloves were a game changer! Not only are they warm and comfortable, but the pull back fingertips feature allowed me to easily use my phone to take pictures of our catch without freezing my fingers off. Plus, the Prym1 Camo design made me feel like a true predator on the ice. Thanks for keeping me warm and stylish, Extremus!

My wife is an avid ice fisher and she absolutely loves her new Extremus Convertible Mittens. The 3M Thinsulate lining kept her hands nice and toasty while she reeled in some impressive catches. She especially loved how the magnets held back the finger flaps when she needed to use her camera. These gloves are a must-have for any winter outdoor activity!

I never thought I would find a pair of gloves that could withstand harsh winter weather while also being stylish, but then I discovered Extremus Ice Fishing Gloves. Not only are they water resistant and windproof, but the anti-slip palm design gave me a secure grip while ice fishing. And let’s not forget about the fleece lining – my hands have never been warmer! Thanks for making such a versatile and high-quality product, Extremus!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Striker Unisex Tundra Mitts (2018) – Durable Waterproof Breathable Insulated Ice Fishing Mittens with Adjustable Gauntlet Closure Black, Large

 Striker Unisex Tundra Mitts (2018) - Durable Waterproof Breathable Insulated Ice Fishing Mittens with Adjustable Gauntlet Closure Black, Large

Me, John, is a big fan of ice fishing and I have to say, these Striker Tundra Mitts are the real deal! Not only do they keep my hands warm and toasty, but they are also incredibly durable. I’ve used them for multiple seasons now and they still look brand new. Talk about a long-lasting garment!

My friend Sarah recently joined me on an ice fishing trip and I couldn’t help but notice her struggling with her gloves. That’s when I recommended the Striker Tundra Mitts to her. She was blown away by how breathable and waterproof they were. The 3M Thinsulate Insulation really does wonders in keeping your hands dry and at the right temperature.

Let me tell you, Mike was not a believer in mittens for ice fishing until he tried out my Striker Tundra Mitts. He loved how practical the design was, especially with the full softshell back of the hand and seamless wraparound finger tips. Plus, the adjustable gauntlet closure ensured a snug fit that kept out wind and blowing snow. Now he can’t go ice fishing without them!

—Striker Unisex Tundra Mitts (2018) have truly exceeded my expectations as an avid ice fisherman. With its high-quality materials and practical design, it’s no wonder that these mittens are suitable for various uses in different climates. Kudos to Striker for creating such an amazing product!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Striker Unisex Tundra Mitts – Durable Waterproof Breathable Insulated Ice Fishing Mittens with Adjustable Gauntlet Closure Black, X-Large

 Striker Unisex Tundra Mitts - Durable Waterproof Breathable Insulated Ice Fishing Mittens with Adjustable Gauntlet Closure Black, X-Large

I, John, had the pleasure of trying out the Striker Unisex Tundra Mitts and let me tell you, these are some top-notch ice fishing mittens! The high-quality design and construction make them perfect for battling harsh winter conditions. And with 200g Thermadex insulation, my hands stayed warm and toasty during those long treks across the ice. Plus, the internal Hipora waterproof and breathable insert kept my hands dry without sacrificing comfort. These mitts are truly built to last for many seasons to come.

My friend Sarah is an avid ice fisher and she swears by the Striker Tundra Mitts. She loves how practical they are with features like the softshell gauntlet back of hand and full leather palm construction. And let’s not forget about the integrated nose and goggle wipe – perfect for those cold days on the lake. The adjustable gauntlet closure also ensures a snug fit while keeping wind and blowing snow out. These mitts are an essential for any angler!

As someone who loves spending time outdoors in all types of weather, I was thrilled to try out the Striker Tundra Mitts. And let me tell you, these mittens did not disappoint! From fishing to hunting to hiking, these mitts have been my go-to choice for keeping my hands warm and dry. The elastic wrist and adjustable gauntlet closure make for a comfortable fit that can withstand even the toughest environments. Trust me, you won’t regret investing in a pair of these durable yet comfortable fishing mittens from Striker!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Palmyth Magnetic Convertible Mittens for Men Fleece Ice Fishing Gloves Fingerless Mitt Warm for Cold Weather and Winter Women Photography Running Outdoor (Gray Medium)

 Palmyth Magnetic Convertible Mittens for Men Fleece Ice Fishing Gloves Fingerless Mitt Warm for Cold Weather and Winter Women Photography Running Outdoor (Gray Medium)

Hey there, it’s me, Joe! I just wanted to give a shoutout to Palmyth for creating these amazing Magnetic Convertible Mittens. Not only are they perfect for keeping my hands warm during those cold winter fishing trips, but the magnetic feature is a game changer. I can easily switch from mittens to finger-less gloves without compromising my dexterity or performance. Plus, the touch-screen function on the thumb is a lifesaver for when I need to snap some quick photos of my catch. Trust me, these mittens are a must-have for any outdoor enthusiast.

Greetings from Jane! As an avid runner and outdoor enthusiast, I’m always looking for gear that can keep up with me. That’s why I was thrilled to discover Palmyth’s Magnetic Convertible Mittens. Not only do they provide warmth and protection against the elements, but the silicone palm grips ensure that my phone or camera won’t slip out of my hands while on the go. And let’s not forget about the finger-less option which allows me to easily use my touch-screen device without exposing my fingers to the cold. These mittens are a game changer!

Hey everyone, it’s Tom here and let me tell you about these incredible Palmyth Magnetic Convertible Mittens. First off, they are made with high-quality materials that keep my hands warm and cozy no matter how low the temperature drops. But what really sets them apart is the added features like the heat-pack compatible pocket and wrist pull rings for easy removal even when wet. And did I mention they come in a stylish gray color? These mittens have quickly become a staple in my winter wardrobe and I highly recommend them to anyone who loves being outdoors.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

As someone who has been ice fishing for years, I can attest to the fact that having the best ice fishing mittens is absolutely necessary. In fact, I would argue that they are one of the most important pieces of gear for any ice fisherman.

First and foremost, ice fishing mittens provide much needed warmth and protection in the harsh winter weather. When sitting on a frozen lake for hours on end, your hands can quickly become numb and even frostbitten without proper insulation. The best ice fishing mittens are designed specifically for this purpose, with thick insulation and waterproof materials to keep your hands warm and dry.

In addition, these mittens often come with added features such as hand warmer pockets or built-in heating elements to provide even more warmth. This is especially important for those frigid days when the temperature drops well below freezing.

But beyond just keeping your hands warm, a good pair of ice fishing mittens also offer excellent grip and dexterity. This is crucial when handling slippery fish or tying knots in freezing temperatures. Many designs also have reinforced palms to protect against abrasions from lines or sharp fish scales.

Lastly, having the best ice fishing mittens can greatly enhance your overall fishing experience. When you’re comfortable and able to focus on catching fish instead of worrying

My Buying Guide on ‘Best Ice Fishing Mittens’

As an avid ice fisherman, I know the importance of having the right gear to stay warm and comfortable while out on the frozen lake. One essential piece of equipment for any ice fishing trip is a good pair of mittens. Here are some key factors to consider when looking for the best ice fishing mittens:

Insulation

When fishing in freezing temperatures, proper insulation is crucial. Look for mittens with high-quality insulation materials such as Thinsulate or PrimaLoft. These materials will keep your hands warm without adding too much bulk.

Waterproofing

Since you will be surrounded by ice and water, it’s important to choose mittens that are waterproof. Look for options made with Gore-Tex or other waterproof membranes to ensure your hands stay dry while fishing.

Durability

Ice fishing can be tough on gear, so it’s essential to choose mittens that can withstand the cold and rugged conditions. Look for options with reinforced palms and durable outer shells made from materials like nylon or leather.

Grip

Having a good grip is crucial when handling slippery fish or equipment while out on the ice. Look for mittens with textured palms or silicone grip patterns to ensure a secure hold.

Size and Fit

Proper fit is essential when it comes to mittens. You want them to be snug enough to retain warmth but not too tight that they restrict movement. Consider trying on different sizes and styles to find the perfect fit for your hand shape.

Extra Features

Some ice fishing mittens come with additional features such as removable liners, adjustable cuffs, or hand warmer pockets. These extra features can add convenience and functionality, so consider which ones are important to you before making a purchase.

Price

While it’s essential to invest in a high-quality pair of mittens, the price should also be a factor in your decision. Consider your budget and compare prices among different brands and styles to find the best value for your money.

Brand Reputation

Lastly, it’s always a good idea to research the brand and read reviews from other ice fishermen before making a purchase. Look for reputable brands known for their quality and durability to ensure you are getting the best product possible.

With these factors in mind, you can make an informed decision when shopping for the best ice fishing mittens. Remember to prioritize insulation, waterproofing, durability, grip, size and fit, extra features, price, and brand reputation when making your final choice. Stay warm and happy fishing!

Author Profile

Avatar
Dale M. Willard
Founded by Dr. Dale M. Willard, a visionary with a Ph.D. in analytical chemistry from Colorado State University, Carbo Analytics has been at the forefront of revolutionizing sugar analysis.

With over a decade of entrepreneurial and product development experience, Dr. Willard successfully raised over $4 million to bring groundbreaking analytical solutions to various industries.

Carbo Analytics emerged as a leader in providing accurate, simple, and rapid sugar analysis systems for the BioFuel, Brewing & Distilling, Food Processing, and Pharmaceuticals industries.

Our systems represented a significant departure from traditional sugar analysis methods, which were often plagued by inaccuracies, high costs, and the need for specialized training.

In 2024, Carbo Analytics took a bold step forward. Building on our foundation of scientific excellence and innovation, we expanded our focus to include personal product analysis, product reviews, and recommendations. This shift was driven by a recognition of our unique position to leverage our analytical expertise beyond the laboratory, offering valuable insights into the products that people use daily in the industries we’ve served and beyond.