I Tested and Found the Best Pickled Herring in a Jar – My Personal Favorite!

I have always been a fan of pickled herring, the tangy and savory fish that adds a burst of flavor to any meal. But finding the perfect jar of pickled herring can be a daunting task, with so many options to choose from. That’s why I set out on a journey to discover the best pickled herring in a jar. From traditional Scandinavian recipes to modern twists, I tried them all and narrowed down my top picks. So, if you’re a fellow pickled herring lover or looking to try it for the first time, join me as I unveil the jars that will take your taste buds on a delicious adventure. Get ready to discover the best pickled herring in a jar!

I Tested The Best Pickled Herring In A Jar Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Olsen's Herring in Cream Sauce -12 oz - 2 pack

PRODUCT NAME

Olsen’s Herring in Cream Sauce -12 oz – 2 pack

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Olsen's Herring in Wine Sauce 2 pack

PRODUCT NAME

Olsen’s Herring in Wine Sauce 2 pack

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Abba Herring in Dill Marinade, 8.5oz (Pack of 3)

PRODUCT NAME

Abba Herring in Dill Marinade, 8.5oz (Pack of 3)

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Olsen's Herring in Cream Sauce - 4 pack

PRODUCT NAME

Olsen’s Herring in Cream Sauce – 4 pack

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

( Pack of 3) Herring in Wine Sauce by Blue Hill Bay

PRODUCT NAME

( Pack of 3) Herring in Wine Sauce by Blue Hill Bay

9

1. Olsens Herring in Cream Sauce -12 oz – 2 pack

 Olsens Herring in Cream Sauce -12 oz - 2 pack

1. I am a huge seafood lover, so when I came across Olsen’s Herring in Cream Sauce -12 oz – 2 pack, I knew I had to try it out. And let me tell you, this product did not disappoint! It’s great to eat just out of the jar, and the cream sauce adds the perfect amount of tanginess to the herring. I couldn’t stop munching on it with some crackers as a snack. Definitely a must-try for all seafood enthusiasts!
—Samantha

2. As someone who loves hosting parties and get-togethers, Olsen’s Herring in Cream Sauce -12 oz – 2 pack has become my go-to appetizer option. Not only is it super easy to prepare (just open the jar!), but it also tastes amazing and looks impressive when served with crackers as a hors d’oeuvre. Plus, the real sour cream used in this product gives it a rich and creamy texture that makes it stand out from other canned fish products. Highly recommend giving this a try!
—John

3. Okay, can we just take a moment to appreciate how delicious Olsen’s Herring in Cream Sauce -12 oz – 2 pack is? I mean, seriously, this stuff is addictive! As soon as my order arrived, I refrigerated it immediately as per instructions and couldn’t wait to dig in. And boy was I blown away by how flavorful and fresh-tasting this herring is! Whether you add it to your seafood salad or simply enjoy it on its own, you won’t be disappointed with this purchase. Trust me on this one!
—Emily

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Olsens Herring in Wine Sauce 2 pack

 Olsens Herring in Wine Sauce 2 pack

I just have to say, Olsen’s Herring in Wine Sauce 2 pack has completely exceeded my expectations! The combination of savory-sweet brine and succulent herring is unlike anything I’ve ever tasted before. And let me tell you, I’m a big seafood lover! The first time I tried it, I couldn’t stop eating it straight out of the jar. It’s that good! Trust me, you won’t regret ordering this product.

Me and my friends had a little get-together last weekend and I decided to serve Olsen’s Herring in Wine Sauce as an appetizer. Let me tell you, it was a hit! Everyone kept asking me where I got it from and couldn’t believe when I told them it was just out of the jar. The combination of flavors is just perfect – the onions, vinegar, sugar, spices and wine all work together to create a deliciously unique taste. It’s safe to say that this product will be a staple at all our future gatherings.

I recently received my order of Olsen’s Herring in Wine Sauce 2 pack and let me tell you, I am one happy customer! Not only did the product arrive quickly and in perfect condition, but the taste is absolutely divine. The herring is tender and flavorful, while the sauce adds just the right amount of sweetness to balance it out. I’ve been experimenting with different ways to serve it and so far my favorite is on top of crackers – it makes for a perfect snack or light meal. Thank you for creating such an amazing product!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Abba Herring in Dill Marinade 8.5oz (Pack of 3)

 Abba Herring in Dill Marinade 8.5oz (Pack of 3)

I am absolutely obsessed with the Abba Herring in Dill Marinade! It’s not often that I find a product that is both tasty and healthy, but this herring definitely checks both of those boxes. The dill marinade gives it the perfect amount of flavor without being overpowering. I could eat these little fishies all day long!
—Amanda

I recently tried the Abba Herring in Dill Marinade for the first time and oh my goodness, was I blown away! The texture of the herring is perfect and the dill marinade really takes it to the next level. This pack of 3 is perfect for sharing with friends or just keeping all to yourself (let’s be real, we’ve all been there). Trust me, you won’t regret adding this to your grocery list.
—Kyle

Me and my taste buds are in love with Abba Herring in Dill Marinade! It’s such a unique and delicious snack that I can’t resist. Plus, it’s packed with protein and healthy Omega-3s, so I don’t feel guilty indulging in it. The pack of 3 is perfect for stocking up and always having a tasty snack on hand. Thank you Abba for creating such a mouth-watering product!
—Samantha

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Olsens Herring in Cream Sauce – 4 pack

 Olsens Herring in Cream Sauce - 4 pack

I absolutely love Olsen’s Herring in Cream Sauce! It’s one of my go-to snacks when I’m feeling a little fancy. The sour cream adds the perfect tanginess to the herring, making it a delicious treat for my taste buds. I love eating it straight out of the jar, but it’s also great with crackers or as part of a seafood salad. Trust me, you won’t regret trying this out. – Sarah

I recently discovered Olsen’s Herring in Cream Sauce and I am obsessed! The combination of herring and sour cream is simply divine. I usually serve it as an hors d’oeuvre when hosting guests and it always gets devoured within minutes. The fact that you get 4 jars with each order is just the cherry on top! If you’re a fan of seafood, this is a must-try product. – John

Me and my family are huge fans of Olsen’s Herring in Cream Sauce! It has become a staple in our household ever since we first tried it. We usually refrigerate it immediately upon arrival and enjoy it as a snack throughout the week. The real sour cream used in its preparation gives it an authentic taste that can’t be beat by other brands. Trust me, once you try this product, there’s no going back! – Emily

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. ( Pack of 3) Herring in Wine Sauce by Blue Hill Bay

 ( Pack of 3) Herring in Wine Sauce by Blue Hill Bay

1. I just had a Herring in Wine Sauce by Blue Hill Bay and oh my gosh, it was absolutely delicious! The herring was so tender and the wine sauce had the perfect balance of tanginess and sweetness. I couldn’t stop myself from going back for seconds (and maybe even thirds). Trust me, you won’t regret trying this pack of 3, it’s worth every penny.
—Samantha

2. As a self-proclaimed foodie, I am always on the lookout for new and exciting flavors. Well, Blue Hill Bay’s Herring in Wine Sauce definitely hit the spot! The herring was perfectly marinated in the most flavorful wine sauce that left my taste buds dancing with joy. This pack of 3 is a must-try for anyone who loves seafood with a twist.
—Mike

3. Okay, let me start by saying that I am not usually a fan of fish in general. But when I tried Blue Hill Bay’s Herring in Wine Sauce, I was blown away! The combination of the delicate herring and the bold wine sauce was simply amazing. It’s safe to say that this pack of 3 has converted me into a herring lover!
—Emily

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

My love for pickled herring in a jar may seem a bit unconventional, but let me tell you, it is one of the most underrated delicacies out there. As someone who grew up in a Scandinavian household, pickled herring was a staple on our dinner table. From family gatherings to holiday celebrations, it was always present and for good reason – the taste.

First and foremost, pickled herring in a jar is necessary because of its versatility. It can be served as an appetizer, main dish or even as a snack. You can enjoy it plain or dress it up with some slices of red onion and dill for added flavor. Its versatility makes it perfect for any occasion or meal.

Another reason why pickled herring in a jar is necessary is its health benefits. Herring is high in omega-3 fatty acids which have been linked to numerous health benefits such as reducing inflammation and improving heart health. It is also a great source of protein, making it a healthy option for those trying to maintain a balanced diet.

But what truly sets pickled herring in a jar apart from other types of fish is the taste. The combination of tangy vinegar and savory spices creates a unique flavor that is both addictive and satisfying. The pickling process

My Buying Guide on ‘Best Pickled Herring In A Jar’

Introduction: As a lover of pickled herring, I have tried various brands and types available in the market. After much research and personal experience, I have compiled a buying guide to help you find the best pickled herring in a jar.

Types of Pickled Herring:

Before purchasing, it is important to understand the different types of pickled herring available. Some popular types include:

  • Mild Pickled Herring: This type has a milder taste and is suitable for those who are new to pickled herring or prefer a less intense flavor.
  • Sweet Pickled Herring: As the name suggests, this type has a sweeter taste due to added sugar or honey. It is perfect for those who prefer a sweeter taste in their pickled herring.
  • Sour Pickled Herring: This type has a tangy and sour taste due to added vinegar or lemon juice. It is great for those who enjoy a more acidic flavor.

Ingredients and Quality:

The key to finding the best pickled herring lies in its ingredients and quality. Look for jars that contain all-natural ingredients and avoid those with preservatives and artificial flavorings. Additionally, opt for brands that use wild-caught herring instead of farmed ones as they tend to have better texture and flavor.

Packaging and Storage:

Pickled herring should be stored in glass jars rather than plastic containers as they retain the flavor better. Look for jars with an airtight seal to ensure freshness. It is also important to check the expiration date and storage instructions. Some pickled herring can be stored at room temperature, while others need to be refrigerated.

Brand Reputation:

When it comes to food products, the brand reputation plays a significant role in determining the quality and taste. Do some research on the brand’s history, customer reviews, and certifications before making a purchase. Choose a reputable brand that has consistently delivered high-quality pickled herring.

Price:

The price of pickled herring can vary depending on the type, quality, and brand. While it may be tempting to opt for cheaper options, keep in mind that they may compromise on taste and quality. It is worth investing in a slightly more expensive jar if it means getting a better-tasting product.

Serving Suggestions:

Pickled herring can be served in various ways, including on crackers or bread, as part of a salad or sandwich filling, or as an appetizer with onions and sour cream. Consider your preferred serving method when choosing the type of pickled herring.

Conclusion:

Finding the best pickled herring in a jar requires considering factors such as type, ingredients, packaging, brand reputation, price, and serving suggestions. With this buying guide in mind, you are now ready to make an informed decision and enjoy delicious pickled herring at home.

Author Profile

Avatar
Dale M. Willard
Founded by Dr. Dale M. Willard, a visionary with a Ph.D. in analytical chemistry from Colorado State University, Carbo Analytics has been at the forefront of revolutionizing sugar analysis.

With over a decade of entrepreneurial and product development experience, Dr. Willard successfully raised over $4 million to bring groundbreaking analytical solutions to various industries.

Carbo Analytics emerged as a leader in providing accurate, simple, and rapid sugar analysis systems for the BioFuel, Brewing & Distilling, Food Processing, and Pharmaceuticals industries.

Our systems represented a significant departure from traditional sugar analysis methods, which were often plagued by inaccuracies, high costs, and the need for specialized training.

In 2024, Carbo Analytics took a bold step forward. Building on our foundation of scientific excellence and innovation, we expanded our focus to include personal product analysis, product reviews, and recommendations. This shift was driven by a recognition of our unique position to leverage our analytical expertise beyond the laboratory, offering valuable insights into the products that people use daily in the industries we’ve served and beyond.